Just before we get started, I would like to double-clarify something. I'm not sure if it will ever be an issue, but keep it in mind just in case. We also have something like this on the sidebar.
iGirl and I don't claim to agree on a lot of things. We're both Christians, but we don't quite have the same world views. Therefore, one of us may review a book that the other one doesn't like, isn't allowed to read, or thinks is un-biblical. As a disclaimer, while one of us may support a book, the other one may not. I don't think this issue will present itself very often, but we would like to make that crystal clear just in case.
And now, to our feature presentation...
Book: LOAMHEDGE
Author: Brian Jacques
Genre: Fantasy
Excerpt:
"Where once I dwelt in Loamhedge,
my secret lies hid from view,
the tale of how I learned to walk,
when once I was as you.
Though you cannot go there,
look out for two who may,
travellers from out of the past,
returning home someday."
-- Loamhedge page 36
Synopsis:
Martha Braebuck, a young hare from Redwall, has all but resigned herself to her mysterious ailment when hope comes in the form of a dream. Soon, the dream begins to prove itself true, as two brave adventurers decide to aid Martha in her search for a cure.
Good Things:
1. The plot was excellent, I thought. Although many of the Redwall books seem to follow one pattern over and over again, the book seemed to have a different texture while still having the familiar feeling of a Redwall tale.
2. The book is extremely character-driven, with some very strong characters and good dialogue.
3. All Redwall books are very wholesome, and this one was no different. No mushy/inappropriate romance (as a matter of fact, I don't remember any romance), and no foul language. A very safe read. This is probably the #1 thing I look for in books.
Bad Things:
1. I think there was one or two mentions of 'Mother Nature'. I believe that the Mother Nature myth discredits God, and so that did not go over with me very well. Thankfully, those are only references, and the Mother Nature idea is nonexistent except for those couple mentions.
2. I mentioned before that the Redwall books seem to have a pattern that can get repetitive. Although this one definitely wasn't as repetitive, there were some parts that were a bit too familiar.
3. There are some parts where the writing style doesn't seem to give a good picture, and just seem a bit amateur. This is rare, but slightly noticeable.
Conclusion:
I definitely suggest this book. The characters are very three dimensional, and there are some very funny parts (and some sad ones). There are morals and lessons, and this book leaves you feeling very satisfied that you did not waste your time. The only thing that brought my opinion down was the slight mentions of Mother Nature and the not-quite-perfect writing style.
Rating:
**** (4) out of ***** (5) stars
Age Suggestion:
10+ just because it's a thick book and a bit intimidating for a younger reader.
Yours without wax,
Izori
iGirl and I don't claim to agree on a lot of things. We're both Christians, but we don't quite have the same world views. Therefore, one of us may review a book that the other one doesn't like, isn't allowed to read, or thinks is un-biblical. As a disclaimer, while one of us may support a book, the other one may not. I don't think this issue will present itself very often, but we would like to make that crystal clear just in case.
And now, to our feature presentation...
Book: LOAMHEDGE
Author: Brian Jacques
Genre: Fantasy
Excerpt:
"Where once I dwelt in Loamhedge,
my secret lies hid from view,
the tale of how I learned to walk,
when once I was as you.
Though you cannot go there,
look out for two who may,
travellers from out of the past,
returning home someday."
-- Loamhedge page 36
Synopsis:
Martha Braebuck, a young hare from Redwall, has all but resigned herself to her mysterious ailment when hope comes in the form of a dream. Soon, the dream begins to prove itself true, as two brave adventurers decide to aid Martha in her search for a cure.
Good Things:
1. The plot was excellent, I thought. Although many of the Redwall books seem to follow one pattern over and over again, the book seemed to have a different texture while still having the familiar feeling of a Redwall tale.
2. The book is extremely character-driven, with some very strong characters and good dialogue.
3. All Redwall books are very wholesome, and this one was no different. No mushy/inappropriate romance (as a matter of fact, I don't remember any romance), and no foul language. A very safe read. This is probably the #1 thing I look for in books.
Bad Things:
1. I think there was one or two mentions of 'Mother Nature'. I believe that the Mother Nature myth discredits God, and so that did not go over with me very well. Thankfully, those are only references, and the Mother Nature idea is nonexistent except for those couple mentions.
2. I mentioned before that the Redwall books seem to have a pattern that can get repetitive. Although this one definitely wasn't as repetitive, there were some parts that were a bit too familiar.
3. There are some parts where the writing style doesn't seem to give a good picture, and just seem a bit amateur. This is rare, but slightly noticeable.
Conclusion:
I definitely suggest this book. The characters are very three dimensional, and there are some very funny parts (and some sad ones). There are morals and lessons, and this book leaves you feeling very satisfied that you did not waste your time. The only thing that brought my opinion down was the slight mentions of Mother Nature and the not-quite-perfect writing style.
Rating:
**** (4) out of ***** (5) stars
Age Suggestion:
10+ just because it's a thick book and a bit intimidating for a younger reader.
Yours without wax,
Izori
No comments:
Post a Comment